A few posts ago I shared my evolving thoughts about the writing process. Last week I was able to put my thinking to the test. In third grade, kids were getting ready to move from notebooks to drafts. It was a little bit of a painful process because I was breaking the news to them that they would no longer be drafting in books. I said, “Now that you are a more experienced writer, we are going to try writing drafts first and then choose which drafts you want to make into books.” (By the way, I think this same conversation ought to happen with older writers…”We are going to write several drafts and then you’ll choose the one that is worthy of your time and energy for revision, editing, and ultimately a grade.”)
I introduced the third graders to this idea and there were a lot of stabs at trying to figure out this whole drafting thing that writers do. There were some heels dug in — “I am going to make a book and you can’t stop me,” was the body language of one girl. (I thought to myself, I might not stop you this time, but eventually you’ll write drafts.) The following day I brought in this interactive chart. I wanted to help make the process more visible to them, as well as help them individualize it. (The following day we added magnets with each student’s name so they can show where they are working in the writing process.
In their previous experience, students had a chart that looked like this:
Notice that it goes in a straight line. In their earlier experience (grades k – 2), students pretty much “marched” through the writing process as they made books. Younger writers layer their revisions and editing on top of the drafting and planning. In the end, they can “fancy up” their book before making it go public. For the most part, though, they stick with a book until it is “finished.” Here are the circles for a primary interactive process chart.
As students gained experience, we’d encourage them to spend more time in planning and drafting then selecting the draft that they wanted to spend more time polishing. I think the more recent chart does a better job helping students think through the process of collecting and drafting, collecting and drafting. In the more recent chart (top picture) I split the envisioning phase into planning and collecting. I think this helps students be more intentional about making a plan. Here are the circles for a more sophisticated interactive process chart.
The straight line chart has been one I’ve used for years. I could have kept using it, but as my thinking changed, I want the resources I use to change and evolve too. Here is a page from my reflective practice journal where I’m attempting to sort out my thinking. You’ll see there are ideas in my notebook that aren’t on the chart I introduced to the third graders. However, that doesn’t mean that I won’t eventually share these nuances with students. Maybe in third grade, or maybe in upper grades in order to nudge students into refining their writing processes as they mature.
Below are a couple of things to try and add some clarity and depth to my thinking. (It makes me nervous to give such a limited glimpse into my teaching.)
- The video is going to have to be what it is. I’m was fighting a major cold…this is the first time I’ve given this lesson…the first time I’ve used this chart…and I’m trying to find the words that will help them understand this new layer to the writing process. I’m nudging them to try drafts and I’m conscious that I don’t push them over the edge. I also recorded it on a whim, so the quality is the best my little iPhone can do. If you plug in earphones, you might have an easier time hearing me. I hope this is helpful to a few people because between the video quality and my evolving thinking I’m getting a few butterflies thinking about making it public. The ultimate reason why I’m sharing it though, is because watching it has helped me understand the process a little more and I think it’ll help others. Plus it’s less than 5 minutes.
- In the primary grades around my school district, students are usually making books. This is based on Katie Wood Ray’s work in In Pictures and In Words: Teaching the Qualities of Good Writing through Illustration Study , her work along with Lisa Cleaveland in About the Authors: Writing Workshop with Our Youngest Writers, and Martha Horn and Mary Ellen Giacobbe’s Talking, Drawing, Writing: Lessons for Our Youngest Writers. There are other books and experts we’ve read, but these are some of the key ones in altering our thinking.
- This is not to say they are making books because we believe writing a Book (with a capital “b”) is the end all be all, but because that is the container that is most appropriate for young children. They also write friendly letters and cards and poetry and some even dabble in comics.
- The third graders are missing making books (and, really, can we blame them?). I’ve said, “When you go public, one way is to make a book.” My guess is at the end of this narrative unit of study, most will make a book. This is not the only way they will go public; however, it is the way most are comfortable with at this point in time.
- I can’t believe the incredible drafts these 8 year olds are writing. Those who have had solid teaching around illustration are using their background knowledge of making meaning in illustration to craft words that are beyond what I’ve seen eight year old writers draft in the past. It is exciting and I’m sure I’ll be posting more on this.
You’ve probably have had enough, but just in case you want to think more about teaching into the writing process, I went through some of our archives to find some more thoughts about the writing process. Here are some other posts I’ve written on the topic:
Unhurried. Finding the magic in the middle of living. Capturing a life of ridiculous grace + raw stories.