Skip to content

Comments Make Community!

Screen Shot 2016-01-12 at 9.42.47 PM

I’ve had blogging on the mind as I prepare to facilitate “Dive Into Blogging” workshops for the Long Island Writing Project and teachers in my school district this winter. As someone who seemingly came late to the blogging party and only started my blog last February, I am passionate and full of conviction that blogging is a worthy endeavor, for educators and students alike.  Some of the most moving pieces of text I’ve read have been blogs.  How incredible to influence and be influenced by educators and students who share their stories with an online community of readers.

It’s the comments that are at the heart of blogging, in my opinion. Dana wrote about this so eloquently when she described how students were commenting on each other’s writing after participating in the Slice of Life Story Challenge (Classroom). When you write something and then….crickets….it feels rather lonely.  When you write something, and people say it has meant something to them, or they appreciate something you wrote, or they ask you questions or make connections, it feels like being part of a meaningful conversation. The comments I’ve received on my personal blogs, Courage Does Not Roar, and Mrs. Sokolowski’s Book Bonanza and the comments on my TWT posts have encouraged me so much in my teaching, writing, and personal life. The comments have made me feel part of a caring community and I try to leave thoughtful comments on the blogs I read as well.

“COOOOOOOOLLLL!” is a typical comment my students leave on each other’s posts, if they bother to comment at all.  I knew I needed to teach into commenting more explicitly as I started seeing more and more one word comments.  I’ve been reading the amazing book, Amplify: Digital Teaching and Learning in the K-6 Classroom, by Katie Muhtaris and Kristin Ziemke.  In Chapter 3, Muhtaris and Ziemke discuss teaching students how to leave thoughtful comments on blogs, including two great charts you could make with your class.  Then, last week on Twitter, I saw a chart on how to leave comments on blogs, posted by Laurie Pitcher and created by Bailey Higgins.  I adapted it for my class, pictured below.

blogging chart

As I introduced this chart to my third graders, we spoke about blogging comments making the writer feel understood and helping the writer and the reader learn more about each other. One of my students had written a post about hot peppers and the different types of hot peppers that people eat.  He said he likes them on his hamburgers.  I modeled for the class that I was going to write at least 3 sentences, offering a compliment, asking a question, and making a connection.  My comment was: “Wow, J., you sure do know a lot about hot peppers! How did you come to learn so much about peppers? I don’t like spicy food so I never eat hot peppers on my hamburger!” I explained to the students that, by writing this comment, I continued the conversation and shared something about myself that the student blogger might not have known.  Now, from this blog post, both the blogger and the reader know more about each other. Knowing more about each other leads to feeling more positive about each other and helps strengthen our community of learners.

I gave students a sheet with everyone’s names on it and asked them to check off the names as they comment on those blogs.  I’m hoping this helps students branch out and read more classmates’ blogs. There was a quiet hum in the room today as students read, typed, and learned more about each other through reading and thoughtfully commenting on each other’s blogs.

How do you help your students to be more thoughtful when they comment on each other’s blogs? Please share your ideas and help us continue the conversation!

8 thoughts on “Comments Make Community! Leave a comment

  1. Kathleen,
    Ah, the art of commenting. Yes, nothing stirs a conversation or boost a writer’s thinking like comments! I am just about to launch my class into commenting and this chart is a great tool. I notice cool and emojis is not one of the three options on this chart! Cool!

    Like

  2. I totally agree with your thoughts on comments on blogs. It is encouraging to know your ideas spark interest in others. Have you seen Linda Yollis’s video about leaving comments? It compliments your anchor chart beautifully. Thanks again for sharing. I have forwarded your post link to colleagues. 😀

    Like

  3. What an inviting and thoughtful way to consider the notion of writing comments. So glad to know you in real life. I love the adaptation for your classroom bloggers.

    Like

  4. I remember seeing that chart on Twitter and I sent the link to it to my email. It’s a great chart.

    There’s nothing more discouraging, as a writer, than crickets after you spend a lot of time getting something ready to go out into the world. It’s important to teach kids how to be creators of content and how to respond to content (by crafting meaningful comments). Everyone can hit a ‘like’ button, but it takes practice to learn how to leave comments that fuel others.

    Like

  5. The comments I received when I started blogging on SOL last March lifted me out of my depression from cancer. That’s how powerful commenting can be! Writing is a conversation and it’s so much better to have that conversation when someone is actually listening and responding. I’ve learned to keep this community of writers in mind when I write my post and I’m pretty sure that makes me a better blogger. Maybe that would be motivating for your students to realize as well to improve their own commenting. Looking forward very much to your upcoming LIWP workshop on blogging with students.

    Like

  6. I really enjoyed reading this post this morning. Although I am not a part of the educators world, it makes me so happy to see how the art of writing is still being taught in new and inviting ways to our children.

    Like

  7. I love the chart. I have to remind kids to comment. I wish it weren’t so. I require three comments a week and lately I put a blog connection on the board and ask them to “Hack” another class blog. They enjoy doing this. They give me a sticky note with the names of the three students they commented on.
    As we get closer to March, I hope that commenting will become more of a habit than a chore. They sure do love getting comments.
    In my own personal blogging, comments feed me. I also have made numerous friends through the connections. Thanks for this post.

    Like

%d bloggers like this: