Skip to content

GUEST BLOG POST: The Way Forward With Brainstorming

Alan Wright is an Australian education consultant who has worked extensively in the United States and Australia. Based in New York for almost six years, Alan worked across primary, middle and high schools. supporting teachers, school districts, regions and school leadership teams to improve learning outcomes for students in literacy. Alan is currently providing school based consultancy support across schools and regions in Victoria, Australia.

He was a contributing author to Teaching Comprehension, (Aussie Interactive) and the New York City Secondary Schools Handbooks for Adolescent Learners Series. His latest book, Igniting Writing –When A Teacher Writes, published by Hawker Brownlow Education (available at www.hbe.com.au) was released in March.  Alan’s blog, Living Life Twice is located at: http://livinglifetwice-alwrite.blogspot.com.

Brainstorming is a strategy that has many learning applications. In this post, as guest blogger, I want to specifically look at brainstorming within the context of writing workshop and how we can assist developing writers to use it more effectively.

It would be inaccurate to think of pre-writing as merely brainstorming. From my observations many teachers do, unfortunately. This is not to say that brainstorming is not a critical pre-writing skill for young writers to acquire. In fact, it provides an excellent way to deepen student thinking around a new topic. It activates prior knowledge critical to writing success.  Brainstorming allows the writer to generate ideas before organizing them. The challenge remains how to do it most effectively.

Many teachers view brainstorming as problematic. They frequently voice concern over what they perceive as student inability to generate ideas when asked to brainstorm as a precursor to writing.

What often occurs is that students are asked to think of as many ideas as they can around a topic or idea and the result is a minimal list more recognizable as drizzle than brainstorm. ‘How come they can’t do this?’ teachers ask.

Well, let’s look at what happens when young writers are initially asked to brainstorm.  Watching the inexperienced writer ‘brainstorm’ is revealing. They frequently indulge in what might be termed ‘self censoring’ or ‘editing out’ of potential ideas. In other words they think of ideas/ connections and then immediately discount them for fear of writing down the wrong answer. They hesitate for fear of making mistakes. They apply judgments to their ideas before they are even hatched. This apparent lack of confidence or faith in their ideas may also result from choosing a topic they know little about. The resultant list contains predictable responses. It has long been a concern of mine that as teachers we frequently invite young writers to brainstorm, but we omit to show them how this important strategy actually works.

The most experienced, proficient writer in the room needs to step forward at this point of the lesson and reveal the secrets of successful brainstorming. In the same way a magician reveals special magic to the audience, the writing teacher needs to create some sparks around brainstorming.

Let’s begin…

Adopt the notion of ‘show, don’t tell’ when revealing the brainstorming strategy to young writers. Begin by saying, “Young writers watch me closely, as I go about my thinking around a topic of interest to me as a writer.”

Then ask the students gathered before you to time you as you document your thinking in front of them. It is important for them to experience your thinking in action. Use a think aloud strategy, so the thoughts in your head are transmitted.  After the allotted time, say three minutes ask them to provide feedback on what they saw you doing, and heard you saying.

You will probably receive comments like:

“You worked really quickly.”

“You were concentrating on your ideas.”

“You made a list.” (my preferred style for documenting my thinking)

“You reread your ideas to get new ones.”

“You wrote down almost everything that came into your head.”

“You didn’t cross anything out.”

“You made a long list.”

“You didn’t stop thinking and writing.”

“You asked yourself questions.”

Document the feedback on a chart to draw attention to the brainstorming behaviours, you want noticed.  This is such an important part of the process. Then tell them that the next step would be to organize and refine the listed items. Ask them, “Do I have to use every listed item?”  They understand that you are not obligated to do this. They also understand that because you have many listed ideas, there are more options at your disposal.

When I demonstrate in this way, I always sense an immediate change in the group. They are ready and primed to try this for themselves. The change is palpable. It is prudent to advise students to choose a topic they feel they know a lot about. That way, students are more likely dive straight in when their turn arrives. The challenge of the blank page just melts away under a flurry of words and phrases, clustering, mind maps, etc. I love it! When teachers see this change take place, they are often astounded that such growth in thinking appears to have taken place in the blink of an eye.

The brainstorming demonstration is without doubt, transformational. It is yet another example of the power of allowing the inexperienced writer to witness, up close and personal, how a particular aspect of the pre-writing process is conducted by a proficient writer. I am never disappointed by the response!

Don’t forget, the aim of brainstorming is quantity, not quality. We want our developing writers to deeply explore their thinking without any judgmental overlay. They should delay judgment until the list is produced.  If they do this, something of interest is more likely to bubble to the surface. The lists are far more extensive and the likelihood of divergent thinking is enhanced.

Brainstorming used in conjunction with other pre-writing strategies, greatly enhances the likelihood the writing students produce will be of a higher quality when it eventually appears on the page. Now, that’s a good outcome to pursue!

7 thoughts on “GUEST BLOG POST: The Way Forward With Brainstorming Leave a comment

  1. I teach writing to adults and follow your process as well. I emphasize the importance of writing down all thoughts during this stage because we don’t want to shut down our creative side. I begin with a demonstration as you suggested, and students see and hear my thought process. They even see the ideas I write that obviously are irrelevant. They feel much more confident in writing whatever comes to mind when it’s time for them to practice this technique. I also practice the technique several times with the class as a group, letting them pick the topics as they offer ideas and I write them on the board. They get really excited when they see the different directions that others’ thought processes take, which I believe opens their minds to new ideas and stimulates discussion.

    Like

  2. This is an excellent article…. I love the observations that the students make about watching you.

    There is something that I practice in my writing workshops with young writers during the brainstorming period. I call it the “No Hands Rule.” My guess is that while children were watching you brainstorm your actual ideas, they had associative ideas of their own, related to YOUR brainstorming. It’s almost impossible for people to watch someone else getting excited about ideas and imagination without your own imagination being ignited and this can be capitalized upon.

    By allowing the children to call out their additions to the brainstorm list, we generate even more ideas and everyone is primed for writing, albeit on a similar topic. Children are so programmed to only speak when their hand is in the air that I find this a good exercise to practice listening as well. In order for the No Hands Rule to work, they have to listen and take turns calling out their contribution. I tell them, if your objective is to be heard, you need to wait until a moment where that is possible. This takes practice but is well worth it, I feel.

    Creativity is contagious and this more collaborative brainstorming leads to many, many ideas that can be collected for future use. This can also be done in small groups of students with one acting as the scribe.

    Like

  3. I love that you highlighted the importance of quantity. I always enjoy seeing my students’ writers notebooks filled with options as a result of their gathering ideas vs. a few.

    Like

  4. “Adopt the notion of ‘show, don’t tell’ when revealing the brainstorming strategy to young writers. Begin by saying, ‘Young writers watch me closely, as I go about my thinking around a topic of interest to me as a writer.'”

    This paragraph resonated with me. This language is about creating that moment where the writers in our classrooms feel like they are being let in on a magical secret–and indeed they are!

    Like

  5. Thanks for this exceptional post on brainstorming, something that’s often tossed aside when there are deadlines and lots of units of study that need to be accomplished. It’s so important and I thank you for bringing more light to it in this forum!

    Like

  6. Sometimes people believe that workshop atmosphere means anything goes/explore/see what happens, and sometimes that is true, but you’ve also shown by your deliberate steps that there are times when direct teaching and modeling before practice is often the way that effects most desired results. Thanks for the details you shared.

    Like

  7. Such a simple idea of brainstorming, but you’ve clarified it to the point of perfection! We think that we’ve “brainstormed” a million times that they should just get it, but you are right — all we get is a “drizzle.” (Love that!) I never really thought about students searching for the right answers during a brainstorm after we tell them over and over, write down anything. Thank you for your insights and the gentle reminders to model, model, and think aloud.

    Like

%d bloggers like this: