Yesterday’s post about structures and routines scratched the surface. THIS post gets nitty-gritty with the structures I try to put in-place, with regard to Writing Workshop, every September.
-
-
Be on-time and be prepared!
- Create a short list of things that you always expect students to bring to the rug for Writing Workshop (e.g., writing implement, writer’s notebook, and their present draft if they’re working on one).
- List any additional items you’d like them to bring to the rug in the same place daily so they have a centralized spot where they can get that information.
- Create focus spots or assigned spots where children can sit that is near their writing partner, which helps during the active engagement part of your minilesson!
- Remind them they may not leave the meeting area during a minilesson (unless they need a tissue).
- Create a short list of things that you always expect students to bring to the rug for Writing Workshop (e.g., writing implement, writer’s notebook, and their present draft if they’re working on one).
-
Movement to and from the minilesson needs to be practiced for speed, efficiency and sound. While quiet conversations, especially those about writing, are okay, fooling around isn’t an option if you want students to take the time they’re with you on the rug seriously.
- Practice the speed at which kids come to and leave the rug so that it happens safely and seamlessly, which means YOU won’t have to wait for them.
- Practice the speed at which kids come to and leave the rug so that it happens safely and seamlessly, which means YOU won’t have to wait for them.
-
-
-
This is a student’s ticket off of the rug after a minilesson.
- Plan boxes help you realize whether or not a student understood what you taught during the minilesson.
-
These boxes are also useful since they encourage a student to plan out how they’ll use their independent work time, thereby eliminating their need to get up and ask for your assistance while you’re conferring.
- It also reduces the amount of talking since they’ve created a plan and you’ve “signed-off” on it before they left the rug.
- It also reduces the amount of talking since they’ve created a plan and you’ve “signed-off” on it before they left the rug.
- Plan boxes help you realize whether or not a student understood what you taught during the minilesson.
-
-
- After a couple of weeks kids may select places where they can truly focus for an entire independent writing period. The spots should be consistent places where children can do their best work each and every day.
- After a couple of weeks kids may select places where they can truly focus for an entire independent writing period. The spots should be consistent places where children can do their best work each and every day.
-
-
Emily Butler-Smith has talked about creating a classroom where it’s “The culture of having enough.” Therefore, giving students access to the supplies they need for Writing Workshop means making a commitment to replenishing the Writing Center often. However, teaching them how to care for the plethora of supplies they’ll go through during the year is important since we want students to use only what they need and to care for the items (e.g., permanent markers need their tops snapped-shut) in the classroom Writing Center.
- Encourage children to take their supplies from the Writing Center after their plan is approved so that they don’t need to get up often during their independent work time.
- Consider creating a couple of “Inventory Chiefs” as classroom jobs who alert you whenever more Writing Center Supplies are needed.
- Encourage children to take their supplies from the Writing Center after their plan is approved so that they don’t need to get up often during their independent work time.
- Purchasing a hanging pocket-chart that has many slots for editing checklists, rubrics, dark lines, etc. allows children to be self-sufficient. If they need something, they can get it from the pocket chart, which should be located in a central location in the classroom.
-
-
-
Lucy Calkins taught me that you need to wait for every student to give you their attention after you say, “Writers, may I have your eyes?”
- That expectation, that you will wait because you have something important to share with them, creates a sense of urgency amongst the kids. It creates a classroom where one child consistently runs into the hallway to alert their friends who have their focus spots outside that they need to come into the classroom now.
- Once you have everyone’s attention, it’s easy to share a teaching point and give a quick example before the kids head back to work.
- That expectation, that you will wait because you have something important to share with them, creates a sense of urgency amongst the kids. It creates a classroom where one child consistently runs into the hallway to alert their friends who have their focus spots outside that they need to come into the classroom now.
-
-
-
Conferring time should be sacred. Kids didn’t want to be interrupted when they were conferring with me, which means that you have to work hard to eradicate unnecessary distractions. Even though students should be working through the plan they created on the rug, sometimes other things need to be mentioned so that they remember not to interrupt during a conference.
-
You might institute a visual signal, like a hat or a scarf to serve as a reminder that they should be reading or writing independently if they see you wearing that clothing item, which you cannot have on at any other time of the school day.
- Teaching some basic American Sign Language Signs, like water fountain, bathroom, yes, and no eliminates distractions since the kids can sign these to you from across the room and wait for your hand to signal yes or no.
- Children should know that medical emergencies are the only reason they should interrupt you when you’re conferring with one of their peers.
- Teaching some basic American Sign Language Signs, like water fountain, bathroom, yes, and no eliminates distractions since the kids can sign these to you from across the room and wait for your hand to signal yes or no.
-
- The children will quickly come to value how precious that conferring time with you is since, depending on your class size, you might only see each child once a week for a one-to-one conference.
-
-
- Creating miniature versions of classroom charts diminishes time spent copying information from a chart to the student’s notebook. These mini-charts can be pasted into a child’s notebook with the swipe of a glue stick or two small pieces of tape. Additionally, mini-charts are excellent resources to have in students’ notebooks since they can reference the strategies taught in class at home since the chart is literally in their notebook.
- Creating miniature versions of classroom charts diminishes time spent copying information from a chart to the student’s notebook. These mini-charts can be pasted into a child’s notebook with the swipe of a glue stick or two small pieces of tape. Additionally, mini-charts are excellent resources to have in students’ notebooks since they can reference the strategies taught in class at home since the chart is literally in their notebook.
-
- This must be explicitly taught early on in the year or else paper scraps will be all over the classroom floor. If you’re clear about the way in which you want materials to be cleaned-up after students cut apart and paste together their drafts after adding sections of new writing, then you have to show the kids how to tidy-up efficiently after any & all revision lessons.
- This must be explicitly taught early on in the year or else paper scraps will be all over the classroom floor. If you’re clear about the way in which you want materials to be cleaned-up after students cut apart and paste together their drafts after adding sections of new writing, then you have to show the kids how to tidy-up efficiently after any & all revision lessons.
-
-
Leah Mermelstein’s Book on sharing suggests informing kids early on in the school year that you, the teacher, will select who shares and how they share (e.g., process share, content share, etc.) daily.
- Teacher-driven share selection should help the speed at which the children come to the rug at the end of a Workshop period and should impact the seriousness with which they arrive.
- Teacher-driven share selection should help the speed at which the children come to the rug at the end of a Workshop period and should impact the seriousness with which they arrive.
-
-
-
Having the following expectations can help students understand the importance of their writer’s notebooks and why you check them.
-
Tell students that you expect that all students will respect their own and each other’s writing.
-
Inform them that you do not expect them to write illegibly in their notebooks. (You can say: “I do not expect you to rip out pages from your notebooks or to scribble all over a page. I don’t expect you to misspell words that you can spell. I expect nothing less than your best!“)
-
On the other hand, the writer’s notebook is for first draft writing and this is not a time to attend to perfection. Therefore, students should know that their writer’s notebook should be cared for… it should show variety and inventiveness as well as evidence of the learning going on in our classroom.
-
-
-
Inform students that you will check their writer’s notebook once a week and will be assessed at the end of each grading period using a writer’s notebook rubric (Adapted from Notebook Know-How, which is written by Amy Buckner).
-
Assigning a day that a student must turn-in his/her writer’s notebook for the entire year is useful. This takes the guessing out of things… there’s no question about when a notebook will be checked.
-
You’ll want to remind students that it’s their checking day in the same way that you remind them to turn-in particular homework assignments at the beginning of the school year.
-
Designated a special place for them to turn-in their notebooks for checking is useful.
-
Returning their notebooks after lunch, complete with the assessment rubric and your comments on sticky notes, provides students with some direction and personalized feedback, which will help them improve their writing.
-
-
-
Remind students to turn-in their writer’s notebook when they return from an absence if they were out on their checking day.
-
-
-
NOTE: I’ve hyperlinked all of the main bullets in this post so you can click on them and be taken to more posts that deal with the same topics.
Discover more from TWO WRITING TEACHERS
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


I found your site on technorati and read a few of your other posts. Keep up the good work. I just added your RSS feed to my Google News Reader. Looking forward to reading more from you down the road!
LikeLike
First, I’d suggest explicitly teaching what a plan box should look like. It should be succinct, free of anything like “Find my seat” or “Don’t talk to my friends.” That’s obvious… hence the reason they create a plan box. I show samples of what a good plan box should look like by saying, “If I were creating a plan for today, here’s what it might look like.” If you do that a few times, they’ll get it by the time October rolls around.
In terms of checking them: Kids finish their plan boxes at different points. Some kids fly through them and others take two-three minutes. Inevitably, there’s a stack-up of kids for a couple of minutes. However, if you’re clear about the expectation to wait quietly while waiting for the plan to be approved, then it stays relatively quiet.
The first six kids in my class who show me solid plans (not the first six kids to show me their plans since they might not be comprehensive) get to take a bean bag, back jack chair, or lounge chair to their focus spot if their spot is not at their desk. This also helps kids to write solid plans in an efficient manner. Anyone who finishes after that may get a throw pillow and/or a throw rug to take to their focus spot… therefore everyone’s a winner! No one loses out on the furniture thing, but the bean bags, back jack chairs, and lounge chairs are hot commodities.
In terms of approving the plans, I teach fourth grade and therefore use a smiley face system. (In 8th grade you could probably use a check for a good plan and a check-plus for an excellent plan.) The kids love to get an elaborate smiley face , even though it’s drawn in under seven seconds, with hair and earrings, which is the sign of an exceptional plan. Corny, I know.
Checking plan boxes should take about five minutes. It’s basically sacrificing one conference a day for the sake of making sure all of the kids are on-track. I’m willing to live with that since it gives me a chance to check in with every kid every day.
Finally, an alternative to you checking plan boxes daily. You could have the kids turn & talk with their writing partner about the plan they created. You can listen-in to what the kids are saying. However, I’ve found this doesn’t help me drive my instruction as well as seeing each kid’s plan for the period.
LikeLike
i really see many merits in the plan boxes approach.
question: when you talk about signing off on their plans, what kind of time are we talkin? is it a quick glance to see that they’ve got a couple orders of business, or do you spend a longer amount of time?
i’m picturing a line of 25 eighth grade bodies, all waiting for me to check their plans… maybe i could adapt it to be an independent requirement, and count it as part of their writer’s notebook check… i’m interested in this… trying to work out the logistics in my head.
LikeLike
I like the idea of the plan boxes. I can see how that would make their work more efficient and would ensure that they have something to get started on.
Do you ever have kids that just don’t feel like writing some days? They claim to have nothing to write about. How do you solve that? I have tried a variety of things, and am happy with most, but I just wonder what other people do.
LikeLike