Ever since I read this post by Katie Kraushaar, I’ve been thinking about personal narrative and wondering why it is that students, particularly in middle elementary grades and beyond, are sometimes less than enthusiastic about this genre. Like Katie, I have felt the mood change in a classroom the moment the teacher mentions the words “personal narrative.”
Why is this? I’ve been wondering. And, what can we do?
When my children were small, and the days occasionally (okay, often) felt long, I was sometimes uninspired to cook by suppertime. So I’d offer them sliced deli turkey and cheese cubes and carrots (and anything else that required little to no cooking or prep) for dinner. At some point my children began to roll their eyes, maybe because I’d suggested that meal too many times. Then one day I said to them, “Girls, let’s fix cold plates tonight.” Their eyes lit up and suddenly they got excited to peel carrots, roll slices of turkey and cut cheese slices into fancy shapes. My children began requesting “cold plates” for supper. I know you are wondering what this has to do with personal narrative. Stay with me here.
We teachers know how important it is for writers to learn to write narratives, and we know that fiction (at least good fiction) is far more challenging to craft than true stories. Through personal narrative study and writing, we expose students to a plethora of craft moves, structural elements and fundamental skills. That is why we include personal narrative units at most grade levels. Maybe young writers, like my own children at suppertime, are wishing for something that feels new and different. Perhaps we can create that by shaking up our personal narrative units.
- We can use other words or phrases to describe this kind of writing. True tales, funny moments, slice of life, to name a few.
- We can set challenges for writers. Upper elementary and middle school students love a good challenge. Say to them “Write a story that is going to bring us to our emotional knees or make us all laugh until our bellies hurt.”
- We can infuse the unit with added energy. Encourage writers to act out, sketch or record their stories before they write them in narrative form. Ask partners to interview and video one another sharing the details of their stories.
- We can share personal narratives written by authors they know and enjoy. Jon Scieszka’s Knucklehead and Ralph Fletcher’s Marshfield Dreams are sure to amuse and inspire middle grade writers.
- We can make sure not to launch a narrative unit too soon after the start of the school year. It is essential that we not rush into a genre study immediately as we set up our workshops at the beginning of the year. Building community, taking time to explore the possibilities and play in notebooks, sharing inspiring read alouds, free writing, choice writing, energizing fluency exercises, modeling writer behaviors, sharing our own experiences as writers, surveys and conversations- all of these should happen over time at the beginning of the year before we introduce a specific genre study.
There are many ways we shake things up so narrative writing feels just new enough so that young writers may respond with glee when we announce that we are going to write true stories from our lives. Let’s put our heads together and do this.
12 thoughts on “Shaking Up Personal Narrative”
5th grade in Colombia!
I love this post! As a writer, personal narratives are still just a struggle for me. I never think they are good enough! And because they are personal they don’t always match up to a mentor text for ideas about how to “fix” them.
So I’m going to hold onto your ideas and also look for times to NAME the “Eureka” moment so that we can find some more mentors that match our own personal narratives!
I thought it was just MY students, or maybe 3rd graders, who didn’t love personal narrative. Thanks for the reassurance that it’s not just me!
I love all of your ideas and suggestions, in particular the one about not launching it too soon in the beginning of the school year. This year, after attending the Boothbay Literacy Retreat, I started off building enthusiasm and excitement for writing by doing lots of quick writes- instant success because kids could write for a short amount of time and also didn’t have the pressure of coming up with a topic all by themselves. I think it helped, but next year I’d like to do more of that and will also try some of your other suggestions.
Loved this post.
Great ideas! I plan on sharing them with the teachers at my school. I find myself rolling my eyes when my students say they have to write a personal narrative.
Great post, Lisa!
I like the “cold plates” analogy. It helped get me ready for the shake-up of personal narratives. I truly believe we’re salesmen/women in the classroom and therefore we sometimes have to get creative or put a different spin on something to make it work.
Another prompt is discovering the narrative of “a EUREKA” moment.
I fell in love with storytelling (having kids choose and TELL a folktale). But in time the TELLING of “NOW I get it” moments really fed our personal writing and our learning on many levels. These were our metacognitive – process writing moments. We began storytelling “Eureka” moments as TALES – “I just figured this….. out!First ThIS happened then…” or “NOW I get the concept of show more than tell!” etc. These ORAL tellings (often just off the cuff and quick, but powerful) began to include our learning in the world that connected to school. “My coach says….” about the process of a sports strategy. We heard “Music feeds me when I’m stuck, tired, mad at the world!” Often several moments of confusion or almost-understanding led to the “Eureka!” and they were so fun and encouraging to hear. SOME of them became written narratives.
I left full time teaching shortly after I hit this HIGH partly so I could find the working artist in myself but also to help others experience the way TALKing/TELLing connect so beautifully to writing. Thank you for these wonderful writing classroom posts which bring up these memories. I love this blog!
Love this idea of the Eureka! moment. That is a fun angle to take. Best of luck to you with your work now. And thanks for your support of the blog.
These are great ideas and I especially like “set a challenge for writers.” I will definitely share this with my colleagues.
This. All of this. Yes!
What great ideas for fresh takes to help make this work more exciting!
I love the ideas presented here. I have had conversations with many teachers who are hesitant to engage a narrative unit for many of the reasons presented in this article. I’m looking forward to sharing these ideas with them to make narratives feel new and different.
Keep us posted on how it goes!
Comments are closed.